COLLABORATIVE AUTONOMOUS SYSTEMS IN MODELS OF URBAN LOGISTICS
Palabras clave:autonomous collaboration, logistics city, Logistic models (es)
COLLABORATIVE AUTONOMOUS SYSTEMS IN MODELS OF URBAN LOGISTICS
SISTEMAS AUTÓNOMOS COLABORATIVOS EN MODELOS DE LOGÍSTICA URBANA
MARTÍN DARIO ARANGO SERNA
Ph.D. School of Mines. Universidad Nacional de Colombia. email@example.com
CONRADO AUGUSTO SERNA URAN
M.Sc. Assistant Professor. Faculty of Engineering, Universidad San Buenaventura, Campus Medellín. firstname.lastname@example.org
KARLA CRISTINA ALVAREZ URIBE
IM.Sc. Universidad Nacional de Colombia. email@example.com
Received for review May 27th, 2011, accepted July 1th, 2011, final version July, 8th, 2011
ABSTRACT: Cities grow, and along with them, the exchange and distribution of goods and services has led in recent years to a greater increasing interest for the optimization of logistic processes carried out in urban areas. In this article, the main approaches and solutions which have been proposed from academic research will be described, focusing mainly on collaborative autonomic logistics, which is offered as an attractive solution to the urban goods distribution problems in complex cities.
KEY WORDS: Autonomous collaboration, city logistics, logistic models
RESUMEN: El crecimiento de las ciudades y con ellas el intercambio y distribución de bienes y servicios ha motivado en los últimos años un interés cada vez más creciente por la optimización de los procesos logísticos llevados a cabo en zonas urbanas. En este artículo, se caracterizan los principales enfoques y soluciones que se han propuesto desde la investigación académica, haciendo especial énfasis en la logística autónoma colaborativa, la cual se ofrece como una solución atractiva para los problemas que conlleva la distribución urbana de mercancías en ciudades complejas.
PALABRAS CLAVE: Colaboración autónoma, logística de ciudad, modelos logísticos
Issues related to city logistics in the transportation of urban goods, have become a relevant topic in city planning. In recent years, both planners and experts in logistics have analyzed the challenges and problems of organizing the transportation of goods within the urban environment, analyzing the behavior of some local governments, transport companies, logistics service providers, customers, residents, and companies . Some of these challenges are necessary in order to find solutions to reduce the effects of traffic in urban areas and the restrictions applied in high traffic city areas due to environmental considerations, and the reduction of accessibility in very congested places. Although studies have been conducted related to the collection and delivery of retail packages and courier services, urban goods transportation also includes waste transportation in the broadest sense, equipment, and transport of materials for industry construction, and a wide range of other urban transportation . Taniguchi defines city logistics as the improving of process in transportation logistic activities by private companies, with the support of advanced information systems in urban areas. The author recommend staking into account the environment and traffic, the road safety, and saving energy in the context of a market economy through the implementation of some measures to reduce the negative effects by moving cargo vehicles in urban and metropolitan areas. That is the reason why the city logistics management has become a challenge due to its complexity and the dynamics of the multiple processes involved [4,5].
The increasing complexity of inter-organizational structures and a relative shortage of cutting- edge logistic infrastructure technologies for increasing the efficiency and effectiveness of existing logistic processes, combined with changes in marketing, and increased mobilities in cities, have important effects on the planning and control of logistic processes in a dynamic environment .One possible approach to deal with these challenges is the control and decentralization in logistics coordination of the participant parts with the ability to make independent decisions; in brief, autonomous cooperation logistic processes .
2. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
The systems theory, applied to city logistics, proposes that cities, like organizations, should be studied as a whole, since different parts of the system interact and, therefore, cannot be separated from each other. Despite studies carried out on urban logistic models [8,9,10,11,12],in many cases urban logistics is not as important in the planning of a city, as it is the transport of goods by road, due to costs optimization and efficiency in the supply chain .
It is important to highlight that in the last 20years, a general awareness regarding these factors has increased. Some initiatives have been carried out mainly in Western Europe and Japan [14,15,16, 17,18].
Projects and research in urban logistics in recent years
The growing demand of mobility of twenty-first century, challenges researchers from various fields to design and develop more efficient traffic and transportation systems, including control devices, techniques to optimize the existing network, and information systems. According to Bazzan , it is necessary to develop models that involve interdisciplinary approaches.
According to Taniguchi , the mobility problem can be fixed by establishing three objectives using a city logisctics system. This vision takes three principles into account: (a) mobility, (b) sustainability, and (c) feasibility. It also presents a number of characteristics associated with the problems of urban goods transportation. There are systems that have the potential to fully develop a vision of city logistics by incorporating urban goods transportation as an integral component of urban planning.
Browne  reviews the increase in public-private partnerships (PPPs) in urban distribution in recent years. He considers that ways in which PPPs have been applied to urban distribution, together with a detailed examination of the various strategies and policies, bring private capital to public investment in logistic and mobility of goods.
Muñuzuri  introduces the process followed to estimate an origin-destination matrix for the transport of goods in the city of Seville, Spain. This focuses mainly on the process of data acquisition, which is usually one of the main obstacles facing this type of analysis. The model, based on the maximization of entropy, and the solution algorithm, includes linear approximations. The results are shown by a comparison with the flow of vehicles observed in reality, which allows conclusions to be drawn for model validation.
Thompson  describes the development of a series of procedures designed to provide greater intelligence in programming urban bus routes (RBU), which allows for additional information to help making decisions when facing changes that take place in dynamic environments.
The concept of e-logistic distribution is applied to the city by Robusté and Galvá , who present a business to consumer (B2C) distribution model that evaluates the inclusion of time windows in delivery service over variables such as distances logistics, shipping, and stops.
There is growing recognition that transport models (such as gravity models, spatial price equilibrium, inputs and outputs) need to better represent the logistic and supply chains to estimate changes in the arising economy from the application of different urban planning policies . In recent years, charge transportation models, through different perspectives, have been developed . Some approaches to managing the supply chain and operations research have been also developed in order to improve the efficiency of business operations strategy for individual companies or group companies . More recently, some models have been developed to incorporate behavioral performance supply chain management, and collaborative logistic network elements in the public sector [28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36].
3. AUTONOMOUS AGENTS AND COLLABORATIVE SYSTEMS
Autonomous cooperation is based on the concept of self-organization, which has its scientific roots in several academic fields such as physics, biology, and chemistry, and belongs to the research field of complexity science in the broadest sense . The different concepts of self-organization, for example, synergistic, cybernetics, chaos theory and dissipative structures, have been points of origin for the concept of autonomous cooperation . The aim of this interdisciplinary field of research is to explain and identify how a complex system creates ordered structures independently. Therefore, it can be added that autonomous cooperation has a narrower perspective than self-organization. It describes the processes of decentralized decision-making in hierarchical structures .
This methodology is associated toa computer system with the following characteristics :
- Autonomy: agents operate without any direct intervention to control their actions and internal states;
- Reactivity: Agents perceive their environment and respond to changes in it ;
- Pro-activity: Agents represent a behavior and not just by their reaction to their targets;
- Social Ability: Agents interact with other agents and / or humans using explicit or implicit communication.
Timm  defines four levels of autonomy and investigates their execution possibilities using software agents. The first level is associated with strong regulation (not autonomy).In the second level is the operational autonomy (reactive systems). And the third level defines the tactic autonomy and final strategic autonomy (complex intelligent systems). It is established that a major feature of an autonomous agent is the ability to interact with its environment and with other agents. The pro-activity and interaction of agents in multi-agent systems generate emergent properties that are not explicitly modeled, so it is concluded that the whole system is more than the sum of its parts .
The above mentionned features can be directly related to the traffic and transport systems, especially the social capability, which is a key factor. An agent-based simulation model is a set of agents that encapsulate the behavior of different individuals. Thus the capabilities of the agents can be used to illustrate the advantages over a solution based on centralized optimization techniques .
4. IMPLEMENTATION OF COLLABORATIVE AUTONOMOUS SYSTEMS IN CITY LOGISTICS
To define how autonomous collaboration systems can improve logistics management strategies, some of the characteristics of autonomous collaborative systems such as autonomy, interaction and non-deterministic character must be considered.
A system is autonomous if it is guided, shaped and developed by itself. It is operationally closed, which means that its members' decisions, relationships, and interactions are not dependent on external controls . As there is no fully closed operating system, this is explained from the concept of relative autonomy of a system or an individual in relation to certain criteria [44,45,46]. In theory, an organization must have an appropriate degree of autonomy to form and develop itself, and to maintain its identity. An appropriate degree of autonomy can preserve a logistics system from an information overload as it is able to find a balance between stability and flexibility.
The concept of interaction is based on complex and dynamic systems that develop from the different relationships of individual systems. Due to this process, the system develops new qualitative features . These emerging structures could contribute to the ability of information management thank to the new structures and processes developed (e.g. new forms of decision-making by intelligent objects.)
5. LOGISTIC MODELING SYSTEMS THROUGH COOPERATION REGION
For some time, in the field of modeling, it has been recognized that micro-simulation approaches are appropriate to explicitly model the different aspects of choice behavior, to provide the explicit representation of travel, and to include specific performance limitations on an individual level (for example, [48,49,50,51]). Micro-simulation models of goods, with applications in urban areas [11,28,30,32,35], and in regional and national areas, have been developed [31,52] in the last ten years
Wisetjindawat  presents a micro-simulation model for Tokyo Metropolitan Area. The model consists of four main stages: (1) Commodity production (production and consumption), (2) Distribution, (3) Conversion of commodity flows into trucks' flow, and (4) Allocation of routes. The model generates the attributes of each company using Monte Carlo simulation. The four stages are developed through the following: generation of commodities, product distribution, transformation of material flows into the flow of trucks and routing .
Davidsson  presents a framework to describe and evaluate agent-based approaches to transport and traffic management, mainly focusing on freight transportation. In their study the authors discuss the suitability of agent-based approaches to the logistics domain, along with open questions about the systems in place. Ossowski  describes a design method for building support systems based on decision agents.
Collaborative driving is the subject of the article by Halle and Chaib-draa , in which communications are used independently to guide the collaboration of vehicles on an automated highway system. Subgroups of vehicles are modeled as software agents, driving with a hierarchical architecture based on three levels: orientation, management and traffic control.
Jedermann et al.  offer new approaches to managing supply chain based on autonomous logistics processes modeled by software agents. Their research shows the balance between the computational requirements of autonomous logistic processes and the capabilities of current embedded systems.
Recently, the Multi Agent Systems Group in the Technical system Forum (E4MAS) has produced valuable results on untapped concept of environment, especially in terms of roles, responsibilities, architecture, and practical applications, which sets many challenges in terms of modeling, methodology and engineering. Under this approach, Zargayouna  proposes a solution for multi-agent routing problem with time windows based on a focus on the environment.
Schönberger and Köpfer  use an independent approach to solve a logistical problem of transport, which requires repeated updating of an existing transportation program. The system load varies significantly and unpredictably over time.
Brintrup  scans the supply chain. Based on it, agents model and simulate a complex autonomous supply chain administered by computational agents, whichaim to minimize -delivery time and maximize revenue by evolutionary multi-objective optimization.
Table 1 shows some of the urban logistic models with a classification in this investigation.
6. COLLABORATIVE AUTONOMOUS SYSTEMS IN LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT
Creative and innovative systems are required to ensure that the movement of goods in cities increases the accessibility and welfare of their residents. They are also required to not jeopardize the chances of future generations to enjoy a similar or better quality of life . However, in the XXI century, there is a good accessibility to be able to use the profits generated by the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) and Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS) that make it possible to achieve a balance between efficiency and respect for the environment.
The rapid and continued development of modern ICT, such as telematics, mobile data transfer, etc., opens new possibilities for the emergence and development of intelligent logistic systems, which can meet the requirements in autonomous logistic processes. However, to maintain a dynamic logistic system controlled, technological development should not only provide short-term changes to the standard of logistics operations, but also take into account that the introduction of autonomy has a significant impact on operational management and strategic logistics services.
The dynamic and structural complexity of logistics networks makes it difficult to provide all the information needed for planning and central-controlling of logistics entities making the self-control presented as a promising approach. This autonomy can be applied in the logistics processes of adaptation, including capacity building for decentralized coordination of autonomous entities, given that autonomy is an interaction between the entities that have the capacity and ability to decide autonomously in non-deterministic systems .
Autonomy enables and requires new strategies and decentralized control systems for logistics. In this context, aspects such as flexibility, adaptability and reactivity to dynamically changing external influences can be treated independently, while maintaining the objectives is of central concern. The integration of strategic and tactical planning combining operations' strategy (capacity, supply chain networks, processes and technology, management and organization) allows the system to act independently, to compensate for a temporary malfunction, or an unlimited entity, or a relationship between two or more entities. Consequently, independent performance of the entities involved allows a shifting of responsibility in making decisions from a central decision system (whether technical or human) to a single logistics entity. This should be considered in developing a concept of objects self-management in the logistics and complexity of the whole system.
In this paper, different aspects of the complexity and dynamics in modern logistics systems, and the possibilities that arise in introducing the concept of collaborative autonomy were related. It is reported that the autonomous processes can be useful in the management of growing and complex dynamic logistics systems, which would not only benefit the company in the route planning in high congestion, but also allow a more efficient logistics management, which would benefit the cities in regard to pollution and traffic factors.
The city logistics programming is a relatively new concept aimed at increasing the efficiency of urban systems of transportation of goods, and reducing traffic congestion and environmental impacts. However, it requires new models of assessment and planning techniques to conduct thorough investigations before those logistics systems can be used effectively in large cities.
 Taniguchi, E., Thomson, R. and Yamada, T., Visions for City Logistics from: logistics systems for sustainable cities, Elsevier, pp 1-16, 2004.
 Russo, F. and Comi, A., A model system for the ex-ante assessment of city logistics measures. Research in Transportation Economics XXX, pp. 1- 7, 2010.
 Taniguchi, E., Thompson, R. and Yamada, T., Recent advances in modelling city logistics, In E. Taniguchi and R.G Thompson (Eds.) City Logistics II, Institute of Systems Science Research, Kyoto, pp.3-34, 2001.
 Robusté, F., Logística de la distribución urbana, en: I Congreso Internacional de tráfico urbano, Madrid. pp. 14-16, 1999.
 Muñuzuri, J., Larrañeta, J., Onieva, L. and Cortés, P., Solutions applicable by local administrations for urban logistics improvement. Cities, Vol. 22, No. 1, pp. 15-28, 2005.
 Bemeleit, B., Lorenz, M., Schumacher, J. and Herzog, O., Risk Management in Dynamic Logistic Systems by Agent Based Autonomous Objects, from: Dynamics in Logistics, First International Conference, LDIC 2007 Bremen, Germany, Proceedings. Springer, Verlag Berlin Heidelberg pp 259-268, 2008.
 Hülsmann, M., Scholz B., Beer, C., Austerschulte, L. and Bernd, S.-R., Effects of Autonomous Cooperation on the Robustness of International Supply Networks - Contributions and Limitations for the Management of External Dynamics in Complex Systems. from: Dynamics in Logistics, First International Conference, LDIC 2007 Bremen, Germany, Proceedings. Springer, Verlag Berlin Heidelberg , pp 241-250, 2008.
 Crespo, J.M., Systems theory, complexity and supply organizational models to enrich city logistics: an approach, from: logistics systems for sustainable cities. Elsevier, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, pp 179-190, 2004.
 Browne, M., Whiteing, A. and Allen, J., City logistics: the continuing search for sustainable solutions, in Waters, D. (Ed.) Global Logistics and Distribution Planning: Strategies for Management, Kogan Page, London, pp.308-320, 2003.
 Robusté, F., Vega, A., Ibeas, A., Diaz, J. and Moura, J., Un modelo de operación del sistema de transporte público colectivo urbano en superficie considerando el tráfico en la ciudad. V Congreso de Ingeniería del Transporte. pp. 255-262, 2002.
 Wisetjindawat, W., Sano, K., Matsumoto, S. and Raothanachonkun, P., Micro-simulation model for modeling freight agents interactions in urban freight movement. In: CD Proceedings, 86th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington DC, pp. 21-25, 2007.
 Vleugel, J. and Janic, M., Route choice and the impact of 'logistic Routes', from: logistics systems for sustainable cities, Elsevier, pp 221- 233, 2004.
 Nemoto, T., Browne, M., Visser, J. and Whiteing, A., Urban Freight Movements and Public private Partnerships, from: Logistics Systems for Sustainable Cities, Elsevier, pp. 17 -36, 2004.
 Robu, V., Noot, H., La Poutre, H. and Schijndel, W., A multi-agent platform for auction-based allocation of loads in transportation logistics. Expert Systems with Applications, 38. pp. 3483-3491, 2011.
 Segalou, E., Ambrosini, C. and Routhier, J., The Environmental Assessment of Urban Goods Movement from: Logistics Systems for Sustainable Cities. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 207-221, 2004.
 Allen, J., Tanner, G., Browne, M., Anderson, S., Christodoulou, G. and Jones, P., Modelling policy measures and company initiatives for sustainable urban distribution -Final Technical Report, project carried out as part of the EPSRC/DfT Future Integrated Transport Programme, University of Westminster, http://www.wmin.ac.uk/transport/projects/sus_u-d.htm (Cited July 7, 2011).
 Taniguchi, E. and Ando, N., An experimental study on the performance of probabilistic vehicle routing and scheduling with ITS. In: E.Taniguchi, & R. G. Thompson (Eds.), Recent advances in city logistics Elsevier, Amsterdam pp. 59-73, 2006.
 Benjelloun, A., Crainic, T. and Bigras, Y., Toward a taxonomy of City Logistics projects, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2 pp. 6217-6228, 2010.
 Bazzan, A. and Klüg, F., Agents in traffic and transportation: Exploring autonomy in logistics, management, simulation, and cooperative driving. Transportation Research Part C 13 pp. 251-254, 2005.
 Browne, M., Allen, J., Andersen, S. and Woodburn, A., Urban freight consolidation centres. In E. Taniguchi, & R. G. Thompson (Eds.), Recent advances in city logistics. Elsevier, Amsterdam. pp. 253-265, 2006.
 Patier, D. and Browne, M., A methodology for the evaluation of urban logistics innovations. In: The Sixth International Conference on City Logistics. Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences 2 pp. 6229-6241, 2010.
 Muñuzuri, J., Larrañeta, J., Onieva, L. and Cortés, P., Estimation of an Origin-Destination Matrix for Urban Freight Transport. Application to the City of Seville, from: Logistics Systems for Sustainable Cities, Elsevier, pp. 67-81, 2004.
 Thompson, R., Intelligent vehicle routing and scheduling. From: Logistics Systems for Sustainable Cities, Elsevier, pp 97-110, 2004.
 Robusté, F. and Galvá, D., Modelización del e-logistics para el B2C en ámbitos urbanos. En: V Congreso de Ingeniería del Transporte, pp. 767- 774, 2002.
 Hensher, D. and Figliozzi, M., Behavioural insights into the modelling of freight transportation and distribution systems. Transportation Research Part B - Methodological 41(9), pp. 921-923. 2007.
 Roorda, M., Cavalcante, R., McCabe, S. and Kwan, H., A conceptual framework for agent-based modelling of logistics services. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review. 46 (1), pp. 18-31, 2010.
 Meixell, M. and Gargeya, V., Global supply chain design: A literature review and critique. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review 41 (6), pp. 531-550, 2005.
 Hunt, J. and Stefan, K., Tour-based microsimulation of urban commercial movements. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological 41 (9), pp. 981- 1013, 2007.
 Fischer, M., Outwater, M., Cheng, L., Ahanotu, D. and Calix, R., An innovative framework for modeling freight transportation in Los Angeles County. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 1906, pp. 105-112, 2005.
 Boerkamps, J., Van- Binsbergen, A. and Bovy, P., Modeling behavioral aspects of urban freight movement in supply chains. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 1725, pp. 17-25, 2000.
 Ben-Akiva, M. and De Jong, G., A micro-simulation model of shipment size and transport chain choice. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological 41(9), pp. 950-965, 2007.
 Wang, Q. and Holguin-Veras, J., Investigation on the attributes determining trip chaining behavior in hybrid micro-simulation urban freight models. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 2066, pp. 1-8, 2008.
 Yin, Y, Williams, I. and Shahkarami, M., Integrated regional economic and freight logistics modelling: results from a model for the Trans-Pennine Corridor, UK. European Transport Conference, Strasbourg, pp. 3-5, 2005.
 Tavasszy, L., Van De Vlist, M., Ruijgrok, C. and Van De Rest, J., Scenario-wise analysis of transport and logistics with a SMILE. 8th WCTR Conference, Antwerp, pp. 12-16, 1998.
 Liedtke, G., An Actor-Based Approach to Commodity Transport Modelling. Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft, Baden Germany, 2006.
 Bovenkerk, M., SMILE+, the new and improved Dutch national freight model system. European Transport Conference, Strasbourg, pp. 3-5, 2005.
 Hülsmann, M., Lohmann, J. and Wycisk, C., The Role of Inter-Organisational Learning and Self-Organising Systems in Building a Sustainable Network Culture. In: International Journal of Knowledge, Culture & Change Management, 5 (2), pp. 21-30, 2005.
 Windt, K. and Hülsmann, M., Changing Paradigms in Logistics - Understanding the Shift from Conventional Control to Autonomous Cooperation and Control. In: Hülsmann M and Windt K (Eds), Understanding Autonomous Cooperation and Control in Logistics, Springer, Berlin, pp 1-16, 2007.
 Hülsmann, M., Scholz-Reiter, B., Freitag, M., Wucisk, C. and De Beer, C., Autonomous Cooperation as a Method to cope with Complexity and Dynamics? - A Simulation based Analyses and Measurement Concept Approach. In: Bar-Yam Y (Ed) Proceedings of the International Conference on Complex Systems (ICCS 2006). Boston, MA, USA, 8 P., 2006.
 Wooldridge, M., An Introduction to MultiAgent Systems. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, 2009.
 Timm, I., Strategic management of autonomous software systems. TZI-Bericht Center for Computing Technologies, University of Bremen, Bremen, 2006.
 Timm, I., Knirsch, P., Kreowski, H. and Timm, A., Understanding Autonomous Cooperation & Control in Logistics - The Impact on Management, Information and Communication and Material Flow. Springer, Berlin, 2007.
 Karageorgos, A., Mehandjiev, N., Weichhart, G. and Haemmerle, A., Agent-based optimisation of logistics and production planning. Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence 16, pp. 335-348, 2003.
 Probst, G., Selbstorganisation, Ordnungsprozesse in sozialen System enaus ganzheitlicher Sicht. Parey, Berlin, 1987.
 Varela, F., Principles of biological autonomy. North Holland, New York, 1979.
 Malik, F., Strategie des Managements komplexer Systeme: Ein Beitragzur Management- Kybernetik evolutionärer Systeme. Haupt, Bern, 2000.
 Haken, H., Synergetik: Eine Zauberformelfür das Management?, In: Rehm W (Ed.): Synergetik: Selbstorganisationals Erfolgsrezeptfür Unternehmen; ein Symposium der IBM, Stuttgart. pp. 15-43, 1993.
 Timmermans, H., and Arentze, T., Albatross Version 2: A Learning-Based Transportation Oriented Simulation System. European Institute of Retailing and Services Studies, Eindhoven, The Netherlands, 2005.
 Bhat, C., Guo, J., Srinivasan, S. and Sivakumar, A., A comprehensive econometric microsimulator for daily activity-travel patterns. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 1894, pp. 57-66, 2004.
 Davidson, W., Donnelly, R., Vovsha, P., Freedman, J., Ruegg, S., Hicks, J., Castiglione, J. and Picado, R., Synthesis of first practices and operational research approaches in activity-based travel demand modeling. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 41 (5), pp. 464-488, 2007.
 Miller, E. and Roorda, M., A prototype model of 24-hour household activity scheduling for the Toronto Area. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 1831, pp. 114-121, 2003.
 Ming, Z., Hunt, J. and Abraham, J., Design and development of a statewide land use transport model for Alberta. Journal of Transportation Systems Engineering and Information Technology 7, pp.79-91, 2007.
 Davidsson, P., Lawrence, P., Ramstedt, L. and Wernstedt, F., An analysis of agent-based approaches to transport logistics. Transportation Research Part C 13, pp. 255-271, 2005.
 Ossowski, S., Hernandez, J., Belmonte, M. and Fernandez, A., Decision support for traffic management based on organisational and communicative multiagent abstractions. Transportation Research Part C, 13, pp. 272-298, 2005.
 Halle, S. and Chaib-Draa, B., A collaborative driving system based on multiagent modelling and simulations. Transportation Research Part C 13, pp 320-345, 2005.
 Jedermann, R., Antunez, L.J., Lang, W., Lorenz, M., Gehrke, J.D. and Herzog, O., Dynamic Decision making on Embedded Platforms in Transport Logistics. In: Dynamics in Logistics - First International Conference, LDIC 2007 Bremen, Germany. Proceedings. Springer, Berlin. pp. 189-197, 2008.
 Zargayouna, M., Balbo, F. and Scémama, G., A multi-agent approach for the dynamic, In Proceedings of the International Workshop on Engineering Societies in the Agents World (ESAW 2008), Saint-Etienne. Springer-Verlag, 2008.
 Schönberger, J. and Kopfer, H., Autonomously Controlled Adaptation of Formal Decision Models -Comparison of Generic Approaches from: Dynamics in Logistics, First International Conference, LDIC 2007 Bremen, Germany, Proceedings. Springer, Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, pp 341-348, 2008.
 Brintrup, A., Behaviour adaptation in the multi-agent, multi-objective and multi-role supply chain. Computers in Industry 61, pp. 636-645, 2010.
 Raicu, R. and Raicu, S., Transport demand, transport and traffic flow - Key elements of city logistics from, Visions for City Logistics. From: Logistics systems for sustainable cities, Elsevier, pp 37-52, 2004.
 Windt, K., Böse, F. and Philipp, T., Autonomy in logistics - identification, characterisation and application. International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing Forthcoming, 2007.
Visitas a la página del resumen del artículo
Derechos de autor 2012 DYNA
Esta obra está bajo una licencia internacional Creative Commons Atribución-NoComercial-SinDerivadas 4.0.
El autor o autores de un artículo aceptado para publicación en cualquiera de las revistas editadas por la facultad de Minas cederán la totalidad de los derechos patrimoniales a la Universidad Nacional de Colombia de manera gratuita, dentro de los cuáles se incluyen: el derecho a editar, publicar, reproducir y distribuir tanto en medios impresos como digitales, además de incluir en artículo en índices internacionales y/o bases de datos, de igual manera, se faculta a la editorial para utilizar las imágenes, tablas y/o cualquier material gráfico presentado en el artículo para el diseño de carátulas o posters de la misma revista. Al asumir los derechos patrimoniales del artículo, no podrá reproducirse parcial o totalmente en ningún medio impreso o digital sin permiso expreso del mismo Carta de Presentación